The principle of sufficient reason is a powerful and controversial philosophical principle stipulating that everything must have a reason, cause, or ground. Leibnizs modal metaphysics stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Reliable information about the coronavirus covid19 is available from the world health organization current situation, international travel. Leibniz on plenitude, relations, and the reign of law springerlink. Nov 22, 2006 leibniz, in logic and harmony described the principle of the plenum or principle of plenitude affirms that the actual world, considered as a set of monads, is as full as it can possibly be. Gonzalo rodriguezpereyra, the principles of contradiction. In any case, what follows from this principle of plenitude is the principle of sufficient reason. List of books and articles about gottfried leibniz. While leibniz published his first, it was newton who invented it. He has made significant contributions in several fields spanning the intellectual landscape, including mathematics, physics, logic, ethics, and theology.
Leibniz preface preface the essay on the understanding, produced by the illustrious. List of books and articles about gottfried leibniz online. I take as a principle that the greatest amount of essence that can exist does exist a vi iii 472. Some fundamental principles of leibnizs philosophy. Lovejoy distinguishes two versions of the principle. So god is achieved by the principle of sufficient reason in the monadology of leibniz. However, formatting rules can vary widely between applications and fields of interest or study.
Gottfried wilhelm leibniz s most popular book is philosophical essays. And leibniz, in a passage from which professor hintikka draws this survey of the claims of the moderni, concludes that such a principle is the basis of atheistic philosophy. Descartes almost as much as one can esteem any man, and, though there are among his opinions some which seem false to me, and even. From later antiquity to the close of the 18th century, most educated men accepted without question a traditional view of the plan and structure of the world. Principle of sufficient reason stanford encyclopedia of. Physics and leibnizs principles simon saunders leibnizs principles made for an elegant and coherent philosophy. With respect to question ii, there is an important distinction to be made between two sorts of simplicity principle. Why the principle of the identity of indiscernibles is not contingently true either. The best possible world is the one with the maximum of diversity, and there are all kinds of complicated notions tied up with this, not least of which are leibnizs commitment to the principle of continuity nature doesnt make leaps and his discovery of the differential calculus which relies on continuously diminishing quantities. Leibniz on plenitude, relations, and the reign of law. He made deep and important contributions to the fields of metaphysics, epistemology, logic, philosophy of religion, as well as mathematics, physics, geology, jurisprudence, and history. This brings us to the second principle of plenitude, which is to diversify from the bau market and selfprovision, or make, grow, or do things for oneself. Gottfried wilhelm leibniz 16461716 was one of the great thinkers of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries and is known as the last universal genius.
Plenitude and compossibility in leibniz him to configure the world in a morally and aesthetically sound way. While he did produce two books, the theodicy 1710 and the new essays concerning. The principle of plenitude comes into conflict with certain other dialectical motives which played an important part in leibniz s thought. Chapter v plenitude and sufficient reason in leibniz and spinoza, p. In addition, the wide range of leibniz s workletters, published papers, and fragments on a variety of philosophical, religious, mathematical, and scientific questions over a fiftyyear periodheightens the challenge of preparing an edition of his writings in english. By placing his vast writings in their proper intellectual context and by analyzing unnoticed early works, christia mercer shows that leibniz developed his philosophy much earlier than previously believed and for rea. The angelic doctor uses the principle to prove the existence of god. A form of the principle is attributed to the german philosopher gottfried wilhelm leibniz. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools.
The psr is often associated with doctrines such as necessitarianism, the principle of the identity of indiscernibles, the principle of plenitude, and. Leibniz s predicateinnotion principle and some of its alleged consequences. The historian of ideas arthur lovejoy was the first to trace the history of this philosophically important principle explicitly. The german rationalist philosopher, gottfried wilhelm leibniz 16461716, is one of the great renaissance men of western thought. In january 1680 leibniz wrote to philipp as follows.
The core claim of the principle is that potential existence equals or implies actual existence. Name given by lovejoy to a principle he detected in much greek and medieval thought, that the existence and abundance of creation must be as great as the. Cultural history, the possible, and the principle of plenitude. Gottfried leibniz books and biography free pdf books from bookyards, one of the worlds first online libraries to offer ebooks to be downloaded for free.
In any case, what follows from this principle of plenitude is the principle. While leibniz published his first, it was newton who invented it first, although today, the formers is used more. Indeed, the rationale for working fewer hours in the market is not only, or even primarily, about reducing stress in daily life although that is certainly important. How two substances might be incompossible when they do not interact and are not defined by negations of each other is a wellknown problem, but we can agree to pass over it, as leibniz did, for the sake of the argument. Oclcs webjunction has pulled together information and resources to assist library staff as they consider how to handle coronavirus. The philosophy of leibniz alfred weber t he life of gottfried wilhelm leibniz, like his doctrine, forms the counterpart of spinozas. In this volume, lovejoy copiously illustrates the influence of this conception, and of the ideas out of which it was compounded, upon the imagination and feelings as expressed in literature. Saying socrates was born in 469 bc, one makes the claim that the predicate was born in 469 bc is exclusive to the subject, socrates, alone. In part metaphysical, in part methodological, they addressed fundamental questions in the treatment of symmetry, in the relationship of physics to mathematics, in logic. This chapter investigates spinozas commitment to the principle of sufficient reason the psr and its role in his system. The illustrious jew of amsterdam was poor, neglected, and persecuted even to his dying day, while leibniz knew only the bright side of life. For leibniz, little perceptions are an important philosophical insight. Thomas aquinas, summa contra gentiles, book i, chaps. Full text of the universal genius see other formats jn matters of style, swim with the current.
Discourse on metaphysics 1685 new essays on human understanding 1704 the monadology 1714 the work of leibniz is huge and rich with insights of genius. A basic distinction in leibniz s logic is that made between truths of reason, or necessary propositions, whose principle is the law of noncontradiction, and truths of fact, or contingent propositions, based on the principle of sufficient reason. And leibniz, in a passage from which professor hintikka draws this survey of. Leibniz, in logic and harmony described the principle of the plenum or principle of plenitude affirms that the actual world, considered as a set of monads, is as. In the field of knowledge and in the field of mind and nature, leibniz opened new horizons to the history of philosophy. Plenitude and sufficient reason in leibniz and spinoza the. In addition, the wide range of leibniz s workletters, published papers, and fragments on a variety of philosophical, religious, mathematical, and scientific questions over a fiftyyear periodheightens the challenge of preparing an edition of his. While some think that leibniz s version of the principle is meant to be only the indiscernibility of identicals, others have interpreted it as the conjunction of the identity of indiscernibles and. First and foremost, this relates to one of leibniz s main general principles, the principle of continuity. Or, if something is not forbidden by fundamental laws it.
In some respects leibniz himself seems to encourage such an approach to his philosophy. While some think that leibniz s version of the principle is meant to be only the indiscernibility of identicals, others have interpreted it as the conjunction of the identity of indiscernibles and the indiscernibility of identicals. The earliest recorded application of the psr seems to be anaximander c. Gottfried leibniz was born on 1 july 1646, toward the end of the thirty years war, in leipzig, saxony, to friedrich leibniz and catharina schmuck. He studied many subjects and wrote many essays on them, including philosophy, mathematics, science, logic, theology, and language. It is remarkable how leibniz in this principle of the dynamic inclination of essences to realize harmoniously the maximum of existence, unites physical, aesthetic, logical, metaphysical and theological considerations. Gottfried wilhelm leibniz and library classification. Nov 16, 2016 it is customary to study leibnizs two most famous doctrinesthe theory of monads and the thesis that the actual world is the best of all possible worldsas if they belonged to wholly separate compartments of his thought. This simple demand for thoroughgoing intelligibility yields some of the boldest and most challenging theses in the history of philosophy. Metaphysical disputation on the principle of an individual leibniz, gottfried wilhelm on. Leibniz occasionally calls those things that fill the functional role propositions,6 and secondly, leibniz frequently uses other principles to fill this sort of role. The principle of continuity is not an aristotelian first principle. Free kindle book and epub digitized and proofread by project gutenberg. Mar 27, 2018 this essay will explain why leibniz accepted the psr, its various applications, and its place in contemporary philosophy.
The principle of continuity is therefore open to proof, as are leibniz s other principles principle of identity of the indiscernibles, principle. Since there is no genuine interaction among distinct substances, there would be no sufficient reason for the nonexistence of any monad that would. Leibniz combined philosophy with science in order to arrive at a systematic philosophy that, by todays standards, is very modern. The collection of manuscript papers of leibniz at the gottfried wilhelm leibniz bibliothek niedersachische landesbibliothek was inscribed on unescos memory of the world register in 2007. Leibniz, spinoza, and the fate of god in the modern world. Principle of sufficient reason in spinoza oxford handbooks. Synthese historical library texts and studies in the history of logic and philosophy, vol 20. Numerous and frequentlyupdated resource results are available from this search. Leibnizs principle, physics, and the language of physics article pdf available in foundations of physics 3010. They reflect an old metaphysical postulate with roots in plato and leibniz which since 1936 has been known as the principle of plenitude. Although leibniz s writing forms an enormous corpus, no single work stands as a canonical expression of his whole philosophy. In other words, the principle of the identity of indiscernibles pii.
I flatter myself that i have learned something by foll. Plenitude and mirrors of god in leibniz springerlink. Lovejoy reaffirms the intrinsic worth of diversity, as a caution against certitude. Gottfried wilhelm leibniz stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Leibniz s predicateinnotion principle and some of its all. From 1676 on leibniz is increasingly explicit about the significance of the principle of plenitude.
Leibnizs predicateinnotion principle and some of its all. Chapter 3 the principles of contradiction, sufficient. He is infinite, and the creatures derive their perfection of it, while they get their imperfections in their own nature. Gottfried wilhelm leibnizs most popular book is philosophical essays. Leibniz there is no conceivable internal motion in it that could be started, steered, sped up, or slowed down, as can happen in a composite thing that has parts that can change in relation to one another.
No doubt, when we reason in accordance with principles of plenitude, we rarely, if ever. In the principle of plenitude, plato described the universe as a place where all that can be imagined must be, one in which no potential of existence remains unfulfilled. Metaphysical disputation on the principle of an individual. Leibnizs metaphysics its origins and development this is the first systematic study ofthe development ofleibnizs philosophy. Gottfried wilhelm leibniz has 335 books on goodreads with 27 ratings. Gottfried wilhelm leibniz stanford encyclopedia of. A contemporary of isaac newton, he and the natural philosopher feuded over who invented calculus. He connects it here with the monads perfection, apparently meaning this in the 3. Leibniz argues that all predicates are contained in their subjects due to a preestablished harmony. Leibniz, spinoza, and the fate of god in the modern world stewart, matthew on. It makes explicit what was presumably at work in his mind when he made his remarkable jump. The principles of philosophy known as monadology g.
Nov 10, 2017 a contemporary of isaac newton, he and the natural philosopher feuded over who invented calculus. It should also be noted that the above questions can be raised for simplicity principles both within philosophy itself and in application to other areas of theorizing, especially empirical science. What sorts of things does spinoza think require a cause or explanation. Leibniz gives to monads, especially when he wants to emphasize the monads role as a source of power, energy, or the like. Pdf leibnizs principle, physics, and the language of physics. The existence of god is based on this principle, is sufficient reason for all the details, there is only one god and that god is enough.
This follows, leibniz believes, from the principle of sufficient reason together with the idea of the perfection of the universe consisting of something like plenitude. It makes explicit what was presumably at work in his mind when he made his. The fact that leibniz had failed to establish any essential difference between his sufficient reason and spinozas necessity was by no means unrecognized in the eighteenth century. Leibniz possible worlds are perhaps the clearest cases in point. In case anyone else is wondering whether to purchase this book in the hopes that it contains a particular essay or selection i decided i would provide a list of the table of contents for any interested reader unfortunately since leibniz tended to write fairly short essays, and this book is 600 pages long, the table of contents will be quite long. Apr 02, 2010 in chapter 4, he examines leibniz s reasons for holding that space and future time are unbounded arguments mostly stemming from the principle of perfection or the principle of plenitude, and notes that newtons substantivalism also championed the infinity of space, but regarded the material world as finite.
A collection of critical essays, anchor books, doubleday, garden city. Wilhelm gottfried leibniz, german philosopher and scholar, wrote essentially. Nature, leibniz claims, never makes leaps new essays on human understanding, 56. In his description of the universe, leibniz also attempts to overcome the cartesian mechanism. Books by gottfried wilhelm leibniz author of philosophical. Or, if something is not forbidden by fundamental laws it must exist in the real world. This is the idea that the best possible universe does not consist only of the highest kind of creature, the archangels, but contains a maximum richness of variety of modes of being, thus realizing every possible kind of existence from the. The principle of plenitude asserts that the universe contains all possible forms of existence. In a series of notes written in paris titled on the greatest of things, he writes. The principle of sufficient reason, in the eyes of leibniz, supreme principle, very large and very noble. New essays on human understanding preface and book i. Plenitude and sufficient reason in leibniz and spinoza.
70 1566 1272 409 1066 1374 49 1539 1403 849 1555 606 989 1165 1580 1454 1044 658 17 206 128 1328 1426 173 770 1012 792 1491 986 68 563 837 190 104 825 514 1591 14 1050 1409 890 317 661 535 838 1493 127 721 1400